Best Black Hair Dyes

Best Black Hair Dye

Who doesn’t want to have great looking hair? I’m sure, you want that stunning black hair too. But before you pick an overhyped best black hair dyes and make a mess out of your hair, let me tell you the bitter truth about the so-called best hair dye for black hair.

If you have been on the search for hair colors, then you sure have heard about some health issues. Yes, hair colors with ammonia or peroxide are still selling on the market. Plus, apart from the health concerns, you are haunted by some other cons that come along with your hair dyes.

High risk of hair damage, thinning, and limitation of hairstyles- these are the shady deals that make your hair maintenance a tragedy.

So, what now? Should we just stop dying our hair and make them look like exhausted bird nests? NO way! What if I guide you to find some of the best hair dye without side effects?

Well, thank me in advance because this is exactly what I am gonna do, right in this very article. So Cheers!

Quick Glance at the Best Black Hair Dyes

Here I have rounded up the chosen ones for you! Each of these has made their ways to my list with loads of legitimate user feedback's. And those feedback's reflected their wealth quite accurately.



Color Stays For?


Editor’s Rating


Just For Men Original Formula Men’s Hair Color, Real Black

Around 4 weeks

Men’s #1 Pick


Nice ‘n Easy Root Touch-Up, Black [003]

3-4 weeks

Performs by the Name


Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Hair Color Crème, 20 Soft Black

3-5 weeks




L'Oréal Paris Root Rescue Hair Color, 2 Natural Black

3+ weeks

Master of the Roots


Herbatint Permanent Herbal Hair Color Gel, 1N Black

4-5 weeks

Extraordinary Formulation


L'Oréal Paris Excellence Créme Permanent Hair Color, 3 Natural Black

Upto 8 weeks

Lasts Longer than all


Garnier Olia Oil Powered Permanent Hair Color, 2.0 Soft Black

4-6 weeks

Oily Nutrition for Hair


Arctic Fox 100% Vegan Transylvania Semi Permanent Hair Dye

3-6 weeks(varies on people)

The Killer Brand


Revlon Colorsilk Beautiful Color Permanent Color, Black 10

3-4 weeks

Popular by demand


Bigen Powder Hair Color #59 Oriental Black 0.21oz

2-4 weeks

Easy Use & great looks


Best Black Hair Dye Reviews

1. Just For Men Original Formula Men's Hair Color, Real Black | Best Black Hair Dye For Men

Don’t say this one is from a racist brand, but yeah, after all it is Just For Men. I was not a big fan of the brand before I learned about this specific item. You cannot just say anything bad about this product, trust me.

I admit this might not be the best professional hair color brand to run into. But I am sure as heck, this could be the best black hair dye for gray hair(only if you are a man), and it does the job within minutes. So I am completely okay if I see professionals using this thing. It really makes sense.

Now, why is this the first pick, right? The reasons are obvious. The Original Formula Men’s Hair Color covers your gray hairs pretty well. It is super easy to apply and you can time its application period as short as 3 to 5 minutes. The longer you keep the lather, the darker your hair gets.

To be honest, the color lasts for about a month and a half at best. So you will have to apply it on a regular basis if you have gray hairs like 40% or above on your head. The best part is you do not have to worry about the repeated use. It won’t stain on your skin, as you can easily wash it off with just rinses of water. But it is better to rinse it somewhere, where your possessions won’t come in contact with.

To conclude, this is the product that really works as the best men’s black hair dye. I mean, it’s shiny and healthy, easy to use, matches your natural color. What else do you need?


  • Covers the gray
  • Takes less than 5 minutes
  • Variety of colors to pick
  • Lasts longer than others


  • Proudly none

2. Nice 'n Easy Root Touch-Up, Black [003] | Best Permanent Black Hair Dye for Roots

To escape the charges for alleged gender discrimination, I have this best hair color to cover gray roots from Clairol as the second pick. So what does the name say again? Nice and easy, absolutely.

This one is true to its name as a Clairol branded black hair color. It is nice looking and easy to apply. Needless to say, Clairol has its reputation well spread due to the efficiency of their hair colors. You will face less mess than any other home hair colors in the market.

Nice ‘n Easy comes as the best permanent black hair dye that boasts itself to cover 100% of your gray hairs. However, it does reach your roots while coloring sessions which is good. You can even mix it with salon shades. This comes in different colors to match up almost all the quality shades available.

It traces to the roots and dries within 10 minutes, and who doesn’t have time for that? So you can stop hitting salons for coloring your hair. Say goodbye to your gray roots with its ergonomic and precise color brush. The color spreads and covers all the area very easily.

It does not irritate with an icky smell and is the best hair color for stubborn gray hairs. It is a dream come true for such people who are tired of their pesky gray hairs. Mindfully, rinse the color out with normal water avoiding shampoo for best results!

In comparison to the other permanent hair dyes, Clairol Nice ‘n Easy stays much longer and is close to a permanent black hair dye that doesn't fade. If you are amongst ladies with gray hair, this product is definitely for you!


  • 100% Gray Coverage
  • Touches up the roots
  • Takes 10 minutes
  • Fades very slowly


  • Need to keep on for a while(for better results)

3. Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Hair Color Creme, 20 Soft Black | Best Nourishing Hair Color

Garnier is a popular name for men and women grooming products. Nutrisse Nourishing Hair Color Crème is another permanent hair color that does a 100% gray coverage. As per the manufacturer’s claim, the after-color conditioner is enriched with three nourishing fruit oils. And being a noob for elemental research, I can’t guarantee the existence of avocado, olive, and shea oils.

It could be a marketing propaganda, but luckily the product made its way to my top ten picks(this is what matters at the end). You get a separate sachet of grape seed oil free with the package. Coloring your hair necessitates some steps to nourish your hair, and Garnier Nutrisse did emphasize on that. Cool, right?

You mix the oils with your dye and while you color your hair, it helps to nourish. If you can't afford the luxury of salon like hair right now, this is the best boxed hair dye to use. You will have wonderful looks and excellent health for your hair.

It is fairly easy to apply and in almost 90% of the cases, the color matches as it appears to be on the box. The color fades fairly slow and does not make your hair look awkward. It fades by shades and all of them are gorgeous. You can use it for years and still have no critics.

Nutrisse smells great and does not drip while you lathe. Nevertheless, you should not expect the performance of pricey salon colors from it. You will just love for what it worths. Choose your shade and enjoy radiant, silky soft and impeccably moistured-hair.


  • Plenty of shades available
  • Oils to nourish your hair
  • 100% gray coverage
  • Long-lasting shades


  • None to quote (read the instructions carefully if you are using this for the first time)

4. L'Oréal Paris Root Rescue Hair Color, 2 Natural Black | Best Low-ammonia Black Hair Dye

What is the best boxed hair dye to use for gray roots? I don’t know, maybe the Root Rescue hair color from L’Oreal Paris can be the one. If you are looking to touch up your roots in between all over color, this is my pick for you!

Root rescue works brilliantly for seamless shade matching with one hundred percent gray coverage. The performance even gets better with the breakthrough quick precision applicator that comes with the box. You will be able to quickly and easily color your roots in as little as ten minutes.

The package is available in fourteen different colors; black, ash blonde and medium brown. However, from the two natural black color shades, you get the best hair dye for natural black hair. The quick precision applicator comb helps touching up your roots quick. You have no chance of a mess since it’s easy like a piece of cake.

It is not the best hair color without ammonia, in fact, bummer alert! It is a low-ammonia color gel itself. Ammonia free hair dyes are the better for your hair health than colors with ammonia- the rule of thumb. But come on, what actually matters is the amount of ammonia in your hair dye products. And as you shampoo, ammonia-free hair colors fade away pretty fast. So low-ammonia is not even a big deal.

Built-in conditioner takes great care of your hair while its aromatic scent makes you mad(not literally though). If you are a salon freak trying to cut loose your budget at this moment, Root Rescue is the solution for uneven touch-ups & seamless beautiful color from root to tip.


  • Extraordinary for roots
  • 100% gray coverage
  • Low-ammonia color gel
  • Takes only 10-15 minutes


  • Lasts about a month(and that’s okay)

5. Herbatint Permanent Herbal Hair Color Gel 1N Black | Best Organic Hair Color

By the name, you already know what the product is formulated for your hair. Herbatint focuses on using the least amount of pharma-chemical ingredients ensuring a gentle touch on your hair.

As a result, this permanent herbal hair color is balanced with minimum chemicals and botanic extracts from natural herbs. It is literally the best hair dye for natural black hair and it not only gently colors the hair but also gives it the natural look it can ever get.

Herbatint Permanent Herbal Hair Color combines rosemary, walnut husk, and cinchona as key ingredients. So the process takes a bit longer(typically around 40 minutes) to deposit color to your hair. Good things take time to come and Herbatint is a scrupulous example of the proverb. Who won’t wait for vibrant natural looking hair? None, I know!

The unique herbal formulation is 100% free from ammonia, which tick marks the safety check for you. Its permanent color stays time after time without any damage, so you have no worries at all.

It is easy to apply and you have multiple shades that are close to your natural hair color. Plus, 1N to 8N series gel has the ability to naturally cover your gray hair, from the first time you apply any of them. Adding more to the features, 8N to 10N colors boast two tones lightening propensity.

You will find the black color awesome and for those who suffer from chemical reactions or a headache, it is the best black hair dye. The lack of chemicals in ingredient calls for a huge thumbs up. No odor, no irritation on your scalp! You won’t think twice buying this best natural black hair dye again.


  • Less toxic covering grays
  • Easy to mix and apply
  • 100% Ammonia-free
  • Natural nourishment


  • A bit pricey (yet cheaper than salon colors)

6. L'Oréal Paris Excellence Créme Permanent Hair Color, 3 Natural Black | Best Long-lasting Hair Dye

Another one from the same company? Well, don’t blame me while many of the gals are in love with L’Oreal Paris hair colors. I just looked into this product and found it to be the best box dye for the price!

It ensures 100% long-lasting gray coverage with rich color and care. Even replenishing stubborn grays, it conditions and protects your hair. Excellence Crème beats all other top selling brands in the market when it comes to user satisfaction and subconscious recommendation.

You get gorgeous looking hair for a long span of up to eight weeks which makes it the best long lasting black hair dye. Its exclusive TPS (Triple Protection System) is filled with Ceramide, Pro-Keratin Complex, and collagen. This initiates utmost care of your hair before, during and after the coloring session. So the name is rationally justified, excellence it is!

The box introduces a pre-color treatment with ceramide. It helps to protect your color-treated hair-ends from color buildup or dullness. Applying the crème is easy with non-drip formula and the conditioner that comes with the package leaves your hair soft and silky.

Although I noticed some complaints amongst the ladies, I knew what the case was. Every dye has its special enactments on specific shades and people have different types of hair. So, it is absolutely a norm if a certain color doesn’t come out as like the picture in the box, right? Excellence Crème does yield to its specifications and has proven results for black, blond and red shades.

You will love this and who knows if you become obsessed with it in no time. Give this a try out, chances are high, it will draw compliments.


  • Rich color and care
  • Lasts up to 8 weeks
  • 100% gray coverage(obviously)
  • Complete package for beautiful hair


  • Technically none

7. Garnier Olia Oil Powered Permanent Hair Color, 2.0 Soft Black | Best Blackest Black Hair Dye

Olia is an oil powered permanent hair color which means it is unlike any other traditional hair color. Garnier uses 60% oil blend, with natural flower oils (from Meadowfoam, Sunflower, Camelia and Passion Flower) in this particular colorant. This is what makes Olia stand different from most other hair colors in the market.

Its exceptional oil-based formula pushes colorants into your hair, without any contents of ammonia. The oils help improve your rough and dull hair and evidently restore them to pure vivid color. You have brilliantly long-lasting black hair with the Olia 2.0 Soft Black shade. And with zero ammonia, you can enjoy both healthy and elegant hair.

Waiting is pleasant as the Olia smells great. Plus, it only takes 20 minutes to give you the wonder. This hydrates your hair and leaves them up to three times silky and shinier than before.

Olia offers 100% gray coverage in its vast range of excellent shades. From gleaming blacks to glowing blondes, you will feel the radiance and lovely shine. If you are looking for the best blackest black hair dye, Olia has its dark platinums shine series for you.

The platinum black shade introduces the deepest shade. It can surprise you with a metallic reflects and intense black shine. However, Darkest Platinum Brown and Dark Platinum Brown are also great looking colors to try.

This can be the one to end your search for the best black hair dye. The box comes with swatches on the side, so you can check if a shade is recommended for you or not. It helps when you are opting for a change in color.


  • 60% oil blend
  • Zero ammonia
  • Covers 100% of grays


  • Color drips a little

8. Arctic Fox 100% Vegan Transylvania Semi Permanent Hair Dye | Best Semi-Permanent Hair Dye

Arctic Fox is not a chemical based hair color. It is made from vegan ingredients and zero animal by-products. So there is no question for harmful chemicals that can damage your hair. Rather, this is the best semi permanent black hair dye which is gentle for repeated use. It also conditions and nourishes your hair to bring back the vibrancy.

The color lasts for weeks although it is free from ammonia. You experience fewer smudges, a pleasant smell with no peroxide, no PPD and no ethyl alcohol.

Semi permanent hair dyes have potential negative side effects. Arctic Fox is different and has managed to minimize the risks and pushed those to the ground. The brand creates beautiful and vibrant hair colors only with harmless, high-grade Vegan ingredients. Plus, it is a proud USA manufacturer.

If you are rubbing off your hair color on pillows and things that come in contact, it is time you put a straight end! Arctic Fox dyes stay in your hair, believe it or not. It is easy to apply and your hair looks vibrant even after a couple of weeks.

Ever dreamt of having picture perfect hair? Well, this vegan Transylvania semi-permanent hair dye might impress you to be a long time customer.


  • No harmful chemicals
  • Long Lasting Color
  • Stays right in your hair
  • Cares animal cruelty


  • Fades fast on unbleached hair(not a frequent case)

9. Revlon Colorsilk Beautiful Color Permanent Color, Black 10 | Best Permanent Hair Dye Brand

Revlon Colorsilk is that inexpensive dye you heard everyone keeps recommending. Yes, this works and works just great. Revlon is the best permanent black hair dye brand out there for the price it takes.

It evenly touches your root to tip thus giving you a natural-looking color. Hair gets the silk and shine you were longing for. Revlon Colorsilk Permanent Color strives to maintain a good health for your hair than other products falling in the same range.

Just like all other hair dyes reviewed in this article, it does 100% gray coverage. Revlon Colors seem radiant and are popular as long-lasting dyes. It penetrates deep into every strand of hair to bring the natural looking color. Being ammonia free, Revlon is gentle and mild on your hair.

The after-color conditioner adds nourishment with silk proteins for better hair condition. You can be confident with the even color from root to tip. It will remain attractive between your coloring sessions. Apart from the black shade, it is available in a range of 40 dazzling shades. Moreover, the colosrsilk performance is not limited to natural hair. It spectacles magic for color treated, relaxed or curled hair as well.


  • 100% gray coverage
  • Great looking color
  • No ammonia 
  • Comes cheap


  • Lasts nearly a month(which is average)

10. Bigen Powder Hair Color #59 Oriental Black 0.21oz | Best Ammonia Free Hair Dye

Looking for a permanent non-fade dye? This is it, you will love it. Bigen powder hair color is a water-activated permanent hair color which means it cartels elements when water acts as the solvent. This is less responsible for hair damages that conventional hair color products occur.

It is free from hydrogen peroxide and ammonia contents. So your health concerns are already served if you are somewhat allergic. Bigen colors without causing hair fall and lifting actions. It makes your hair feel like a soft raven feather. Honestly, no harsh chemicals and no pain or rashes on your scalp.

It is simple and easy to use. You can mix it with normal tap water and the color is rich enough. Effortless to mix and apply, covers 100% gray, and does not fade out fast. Oriental black is the darkest of colors and is the one you might like.

But be very careful! Make sure your hair is dry before you go to bed. Because the color runs after washing and stains linens and towels. However, the color supposedly lasts longer than traditional hair dyes sold in drug stores and looks amazing. Now let me give you a shock.

Remember my first pick? Yeah, there are few people who have shifted from JustForMen Original to this very powder color. So don’t underestimate my last pick either.


  • Simple to use
  • 100% gray coverage
  • Lasts more than average
  • No ammonia and peroxide-free


  • Causes dry hair (for people with certain hair types)

Best Black Hair Color Buying Guide

Lasting Ability

There are mainly four types of dyes. Temporary, demi-permanent, semi-permanent and permanent. Depending on your requirement, you can choose any one of them.

Temporary dyes live up to their name and get washed after a few shampoo sessions.

Demi and semi-permanent dyes also last up to a few shampoos. The difference is in number. Usually, demi-permanent dyes last up to 12 shampoos, while the number is 30 for semi-permanent ones.

Permanent dyes change the pigment of the hair and last until new hair is grown or the existing ones are cut off.

Dye Formula

Permanent dyes are great in terms of longevity. But the catch is they usually contain ammonia. So people have sensitive skin which becomes irritated when comes in touch of ammonia.

Usually, dyes other than permanent ones contain less ammonia. Apart from ammonia, any dye that contains less chemical components is good for your hair. Often, they strip the hair of essential nutrients and oils, even halt the hair growth sometimes.

Avoid dyes that are less open about the ingredients they use. No matter how attractive the word ‘secret formula’ sounds, it may end up damaging your hair.

Allergic reactions

Para-phenylenediamine, also known as PPD is a common ingredient used in many dyes, both cheap and expensive ones. Many people are allergic to this, but they end up buying the same product not knowing what’s causing the irritations.

The symptoms include redness, itching, flaking, irritation, even blisters. If the symptoms last for a few days, it’s time to see a doctor. Also, make sure you check the ingredient list and avoid dyes containing PPD from later on. There are dyes that come PPD-free, you can choose them.

The Smell

Many people like the shiny repercussion black hair dyes provide. That’s the reason they’re using these, right? But while the color is soothing to eyes, the smell might not.

Dyes, especially permanent dyes come with a strong smell, particularly because of ammonia. Before making a purchasing decision, check how other users are telling about the smell. You can opt for ammonia free, semi-permanent dyes if you’re not okay with the smell.

Ease Of Application

You can always head towards a salon and get your hair dyed up. But that’s costly and demands time. Many of the users rather prefer DIY dye applications. Here comes the next question, is it easy to apply?

Dyeing your hair can be messy if you don’t know how to do it. Also, the product should come in a form that assists you instead of making your job hard. Many products come with additional tools like gloves, highlighting wands, precise applicator nozzle etc.

Some dyes come in creamy or foamy textures to help users who face dye dripping problems. They are thicker, unlikely to drip and allow the user to multitask in the meantime.

Gray Coverage

Covering the gray areas of your hair, especially the roots can be challenging. That’s because they tend to be wiry and often the dye can’t soak in easily. 

Most of the colorists use permanent hair dye for gray hairs. They are more effective than semi-permanent ones in this matter. As semi-permanent dyes fade over time, they might leave yellow tints on your hair.

Make sure your dye offers 100% gray coverage. There are some dyes especially made for this purpose.

Furthermore, having the option of several color shades is also great. If your goal is to hide gray hairs instead of drastically change the hair color, choosing two shades lighter or darker than your natural hair color is the safest and most suitable option.

Bottom Line:

Regardless of your gender and age, gray hair is a habitual fact. But with the best black hair dye for your type, you can still keep the style on! I have tried my best to make this a user feedback based review for you.

Now it is your part to tell me which one did you pick and how it went with your hair. Type in the comment section. Because this is how I improve my reviews for you. Kudos!

If you loved this content, I'm sure you'll love sports related resources from, have a look!

Leave a comment:

Leave a comment: